State Theory
The state has been regarded, and continues to be regarded, as a legitimate bearer of authority—an idea rooted in absolutist thought (Machiavelli 1513, Bodei 1576, Hobbes 1651). According to this view, the state, however it is governed, is preferable to war and chaos. Max Weber’s concept of domination provides an intellectual bridge between this understanding of the state and the present day. According to Weber, domination exists when those subject to it obey a command in a disciplined manner (Weber 1921/1980, pp. 28, 29, 122, 123); domination thus appears to be generally legitimate. Above all, however, the state is still seen today as an authority structure, as in Georg Jellinek’s three-element theory of the state, which defines the state as a unity of territory (a defined geographical area), people (the population belonging to it) and state power (effective, sovereign authority) (Jellinek 1900).
From a civility-theory perspective, this understanding of the state needs qualification. While a monopoly on the use of force is a feature of the modern state (a requirement even the pro-gun Trump administration is beginning to grasp), state power can also be illegitimate, as in forms of tyranny that lack the consent of the population and violate all human rights. States can also do more than operate as vertical structures of authority: they can negotiate, a form of horizontal coordination that led Fritz Scharpf (1993, 2000) to develop the concept of the negotiating state. Above all, the modern constitutional state coordinates itself within the bounds of applicable constitutional and procedural law—that is, in two dimensions. When it operates through public policymaking, it does so multidimensionally.
This means that the concept of state (from the Latin status: standing, condition, position) can no longer be confined by the concept of rule. This critique of an understanding of the state still influenced by absolutism—see, for example, China’s claim to absolute sovereignty in the face of any criticism of human rights violations, or Donald Trump’s psychopathic unilateralism—ultimately reflects an undeniable fact: so far, there is no state on Earth that encompasses the entire planet; rather, nation-states, relations between them, and subnational government bodies operate in an international system of competing claims and forms of legitimacy. No state is therefore absolutely sovereign; rather, public action for the good of humanity necessarily requires a willingness and ability to cooperate.
Anyone who continues to use the concept of the state in the sense of absolute rule despite this has either not thought it through or is deliberately misleading their audience—or both. Above all, this blocks urgently needed political learning.
You can read the full text on this topic by clicking the button below: