Legal Theory Based on Civility Theory
Law is the body of valid rules that all parties can effectively enforce. Only rules that are respected as independently enforceable constitute law—a fundamental difference from thinking and acting according to the logic of power.
Without rules whose observance can be effectively enforced, there is lawlessness (anomie). When rules are promoted and applied as law without being universally enforceable, the result is injustice. Unequal laws, such as the laws governing the estates, have indeed historically been regarded and described as law (ordained by God). But unequal laws lose their legal character when those disadvantaged cannot effectively claim their (lesser) rights. Formally equal laws, too, lose their legal character when they can be manipulated, for example through lobbying that inserts “fine print.” Beyond formalistic application of the law lies a substantive and/or empathetically wise application of the law
This gives us the following gradation of legality:
- Injustice and Lawlessness
- Unequal Rights
- Manipulable Equal Rights
- Equal rights effectively protected
- Sound and empathetic application of the law
Law exists in different forms (such as public law, including criminal law and human rights, private law, and sector-specific forms of law). All these forms of law can be comparatively classified and analyzed across a spectrum of different civility levels.
Law is of fundamental importance in all societies that include elements of civility. It can serve various functions, including coordination, peace and security, preserving and developing values, protecting freedom, legitimizing authority, and checking those in power. The extent to which law is established, and the forms it takes, depend not only on legal discourse that establishes itself, but also on the general level of civility. In war, for example, even minimal legal protections risk being lost. Where power is largely absolute, law loses much of its significance; when individual self-interest prevails, law can easily become a plaything of the rich and powerful. Conversely, legal-bureaucratic formalism can also harm the general welfare.
Unilateral, one-dimensional thinking struggles with the two-dimensional concept of law. In the logic of friend or foe, for example, independent law has no place. From the standpoint of power logic, law can only be understood as the law of the ruling class, in keeping with the statement attributed to Karl Marx: The law of the ruling class is the law of the rulers. And in interest-driven thinking (such as Donald Trump’s), law is an absurdity. Accordingly, unilateralists seek to relativize, undermine and abolish independent law.
For more on legal theory from the perspective of civility theory, see: